Sinéad’s Theology

Theology is an attempt to create a place of peace in a time of war… I observe a lot of violence done in the name of theologies of various religions, but when you study the actual texts of those religions you find that they don’t … justify war or violence or anything really which is unloving of people. — Sinéad O’Connor

sineadTheology is an unlikely name for a rock music album, particularly when the artist is Sinéad O’Connor, the skin-headed Irish rocker who famously shredded a photo of Pope John Paul II on her 1992 Saturday Night Live gig. But O’Connor, a cultural Catholic whose grievances against “hierarchy” and “theocracy” have pretty well soured her on the church, nevertheless thinks of herself as a child of God.

“I don’t go to church regularly, but I don’t think you have to in order to conduct a relationship with God. … I believe you can find God all over the place,” she said in a recent interview with Christianity Today. A lot of people fed up with “religion” would agree with her.

Theology is Sinéad O’Connor’s musical portrait of the God she worships, the God she believes she has discovered in her search of the Old Testament, particularly in those books where God speaks for himself — the prophets.

A lot of people interpret what they think God says. But the only time God actually speaks for himself is in the books of the prophets. That’s what kind of interests me. I’m interested in the idea of separating God from religion. — Jesus is ‘Like an energy’, Christianity Today, July 9, 2007

Taking a cue from the Jesus Seminar, O’Connor reads the Bible like a restaurant menu, passing over anything that doesn’t tickle her palate. She’s looking for the God she believes is hidden behind centuries of Christian misinterpretation. Predictably, her God loves everybody, accepts everybody, and makes himself known in every religion.

I think God saves everybody whether they want to be saved or not… I don’t think God judges anybody. He loves everybody equally. I think there’s a slight difference when it comes to very evil people, but there are not too many of those in the world. — Ibid

Did you notice the wee small crack in God’s seamless non-judgmentalism? God may disapprove of the actions of a few, “very evil people,” but the rest of us can relax. That’s a theology, alright. Sinéad O’Connor’s “church-of-the-God-who-accepts-me-unconditionally” is surely one of the fastest-growing churches in the western world.

Sinéad O’Connor was born and raised in Dublin during a time when Catholics and Protestants were tearing the country apart. Her mother and father divorced when she was eight. Her mother was given custody of the children and, according to O’Connor, was physically abusive. O’Connor got into trouble with the law and was shuttled off to reform school. By the age of 20 she was pregnant and unmarried. She’s been divorced twice and was excommunicated from the Catholic church when she allowed herself to be ordained by a renegade priest. She’s had an interesting life.

O’Connor is undeniably talented and has managed to build a tremendous musical career, despite the challenges of her personal life and the controversies she has brought on herself. She has a classic Irish folksinger’s voice, not beautiful but honest. She reminds me of the folk singer Joan Baez in the way her voice commands your attention. O’Connor’s music is always deeply personal and strikes an emotional chord with her audience.

If you had a vineyard on a fruitful hill,
and you fenced it and cleared it of all stones until,
you planted it with the choicest of vines,
and you even built a tower and a press to make wine,
and you hoped that it would bring forth sweet grapes
but it gave only wild grapes,
what would you say?
— “If you had a vineyard,” from Theology, Sinéad O’Connor (text from Isaiah 5)

You can hear samples of Theology at Sinéad O’Connor’s Myspace page, and also at her website where she has posted a video of a recent performance of Theology mixed with her explanation of how the album came to be.

Theology is an interesting piece of musical art and a huge risk for O’Connor’s career. Christians may not embrace the album because of her anti-religious tirades. Her fans may not embrace it because the lyrics are soaked in the language of Scripture. Her publisher may be betting that the timely anti-war themes in the album soften its heavy spirituality.

Whether it becomes commercially successful or not, Theology is interesting for the way it illuminates one woman’s search for the meaning of life and how that search has driven her towards the God of Israel. Disagree with her do-it-yourself theology, her politics, her permissive lifestyle or her weird hair — Sinéad O’Connor is at least searching for the heart of God by combing the pages of the Old Testament. It’s a good start.

Photo credit: Kevin Abosch at

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. Charlie,

    Great post. Yes, it is a good start for Sinéad. A couple things come to mind:

    When I was younger and searching for God’s approval, the verse where Jesus tells the young man, “Surely, you are not far from the kingdom of God,” was one I clung to. I felt like this man, so close and still not in the Kingdom yet, and I wanted so much to believe that my searching counted for something in God’s eyes. A lot has changed for me since then, and I search and doubt no more.

    The other thing is that I had a boss who was Jewish and a co-worker who was Catholic. One day I was doing my Bible Study Fellowship homework at my desk during lunch, and the Catholic asked me what I was reading. Then he saw my Bible, said “Oh,” as though it was toxic, and walked away.

    At the same time, my boss had started going to synagogue, and we would talk about Scripture (O.T.) sometimes. I had more in common with her than with the Catholic man, because she and I had hearts turned toward God.

    Whether or not either my boss or my co-worker was saved I’ll leave up to God to decide. I know what the Bible teaches. It’s easy to dismiss Sinéad for her off-brand of theology, but God can reach a heart that’s turned toward Him. He reached mine.

  2. Good post. I’m glad you’re challenging Christians to ‘read between the lines’ of others’ comments on God. For any of your readers who want to look further into the question “who does God forgive?” I recommend the book, “Brighton Rock” by Graham Greene.

  3. So many people want a Play-Doh deity…a god they can shape into whatever form is comfortable for them. I wish Sinead could know the true God who transcends our opinions and speculations. That’s where she would find peace.

  4. I’d like to know what version of the scriptures she reads, when she’s able to read the prophets, and then say that, “I don’t think God judges anybody”.

    That’s one of the craziest statements I’ve read in a long time.

  5. This latest ‘theology’ of Sinead O’Connors is just the latest in a lifelong string of identity crises. She’s gone from Catholic to unwed teenage mother to popstar to Lesbian to straight to lesbian to straight. She’s publically “retired” 3 times. She attempted suicide 7 years ago. Sometimes she apologizes emphatically about tearing up the pope’s picture, sometimes she plays the rebel. Now shes singing to ‘Jah’, with I guess is a more palatable flavor of Christian god for her.

    Like most lost people who turn to religion (in this case one after another) her identity crisis is at the heart of her faith. The painful difference here is that its on display for all to see.

  6. very christian of you, armen. not judgmental at all. jeez.

    ever hear of a little thing called compassion?

  7. Jill, honey.

    Armen was simply pointing out that the God of the Bible is incredibly judgemental. Which He most certainly is, no?

    Or does condemning entire nations to destruction for not following stated dietary customs not count as being judgmental? Please don’t make me go get some quotes from your tired old book.

  8. I don’t think sinead’s tirades were “anti-religious” – they were anti-hypocritical hierarchy. An opinion she seems to still hold quite strongly based on your excerpts above.

    For example, everyone knows she ripped up the picture of the pope on SNL. But the reason she ripped it up was that she was protesting the church’s cover-up of priests abusing children – she had just finished singing a version of Bob Marley’s “War” with the lyrics changed to talk about child abuse. She was about 10 years ahead of the curve on that issue so no one listened to her, they just let the abuse continue and called her crazy.

    I’m sure the reason she might regret ripping up that picture is because it did not achieve the intended result of spotlighting the church’s cover-up, not that she is sorry for offending anyone.

    As for her embracement of the rastafarian Jah – it might be useful to give the rasta movement a little closer inspection, its a religion that encourages everyone to find God through their own spiritual examination, a very anti-hierarchy approach, much like those other protestant sects with european roots.

Comment Policy:  All comments are subject to moderation. Your words are your own, but AnotherThink is mine, so I reserve the right to censor language that is uncouth or derogatory. No anonymous comments will be published, but if you include your real name and email address (kept private), you can say pretty much whatever is on your mind. I look forward to hearing from you.

Leave a comment


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.